PURPOSE: Histologic validation of ultrahigh-resolution multi-slice (MS)-CT for the evaluation of focal, experimental cartilage lesions with special regard to the subchondral bone. Testing of micro-CT ( micro CT) as alternative reference standard. METHODS: 32 experimental cartilage lesions in bovine patellae were imaged surrounded by air (MS-CT-air) and immersed in a contrast material solution (MS-CT-CM) with MS-CT (collimation 2 x 0,5 mm). After the micro CT (8 micro m-voxelsite) examination in three specimen and histologic work-up of 29 specimen two radiologist graded the defects on MS-CT images in consensus (subchondral bone involvement yes or no) and results were compared to the results of histomorphometry and micro CT. RESULTS: The MS-CT-air and -CM had an accuracy of 94 % (30/32) and 88 % (28/32), respectively. MS-CT-air led to one false-positive (remaining cartilage: = 0,1 mm) and false-negative result, each. MS-CT-CM showed false-positive results if the remaining cartilage was <0,3 mm thick (n = 4), i. e. showed subchondral bone involvement. Contrast-to-noise ratio was significantly higher in MS-CT-air compared to MS-CT-CM. micro CT yielded a clear depiction of cartilage defect depth in the three cases. CONCLUSION: MS-CT-air has a high accuracy in the depiction of focal cartilage defects. MS-CT-CM has a tendency to overestimate cartilage defect depth. micro CT could potentially serve as alternative reference standard to histology.
