Surgical Experience Affects the Outcome of Central Venous Access Catheter Implantation in Children: A Retrospective Cohort Study

INTRODUCTION: Surgical complications occur in up to third of children, limiting the benefits of tunneled central venous catheters (tCVCs) in children. We aimed to identify risk factors for complications related to catheter implantation.

METHODS: All children and adolescents undergoing tCVC implantation at a single center over a period of 9 years were analyzed. Infection, thrombosis, dislocation, and catheter dysfunction were defined as complications. Both patient-related (ie, age, sex, vessel characteristics, revision surgery) and surgical factors (ie, sex of surgeon, surgical experience) were analyzed for their association with complications.

RESULTS: A total of 1024 catheters were inserted, 887 ports and 137 broviac catheters. In terms of patient-related factors, Broviac catheters, and nononcological patients had a higher complication rate. The use of the internal jugular vein and revision surgery was associated with significantly increased complications in patients with port catheters. Experience of the surgeon correlated with various outcome parameters. Implantation performed by an attending were associated with lower complication rates in comparison to those performed by residents. Within the resident group, insertions performed by experienced residents had more complications compared with those performed by residents during their first years.

CONCLUSION: The study suggests that the outcome of tCVCs insertion is affected by the type of catheter used, the utilized vessel and above all by surgical experience. Residents had significantly increased complication rates in comparison to board-certified surgeons and amongst resident's outcome got worse with increasing experience of the residents. The presence of an experienced attending did not compensate for this effect. To improve the outcome of tCVCs, strategies like direct feedback after every procedure to achieve proficiency should be implanted in residency programs.