Identifying change-dropout patterns during an Internet-based intervention for depression by applying the Muthen-Roy model

  • Alice Arndt
  • Wolfgang Lutz
  • Julian Rubel
  • Thomas Berger
  • Björn Meyer
  • Johanna Schröder
  • Christina Späth
  • Martin Hautzinger
  • Kristina Fuhr
  • Matthias Rose
  • Fritz Hohagen
  • Jan Philipp Klein
  • Steffen Moritz

Abstract

To date, only few studies have attempted to investigate non-ignorable dropout during Internet-based interventions by applying an NMAR model, which includes missing data indicators in its equations. Here, the Muthen-Roy model was used to investigate change and dropout patterns in a sample of patients with mild-to-moderate depression symptoms (N = 483) who were randomized to a 12-week Internet-based intervention (deprexis, identifier: NCT01636752). Participants completed the PHQ-9 biweekly during the treatment. We identified four change-dropout patterns: Participants showing high impairment, improvement and low dropout probability (C3, N = 134) had the highest rate of reliable change at 6- and 12-month follow-up. A further pattern was characterized by high impairment, deterioration and high dropout probability (C2, N = 32), another by low impairment, improvement and high dropout probability (C1, N = 198). The last pattern was characterized by high impairment, no change and low dropout probability (C4, N = 119). In addition to deterioration, also rapid improvement may lead to dropout as a result of a perceived "good enough" dosage of treatment. This knowledge may strengthen sensitivity for the mechanisms of dropout and help to consider its meaning in efforts to optimize treatment selection.

Bibliographical data

Original languageEnglish
ISSN1650-6073
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.2020
PubMed 30721109