Testicular sperm extraction: comprehensive analysis with simultaneously performed histology in 1418 biopsies from 766 subfertile men.

TY - JOUR

T1 - Testicular sperm extraction: comprehensive analysis with simultaneously performed histology in 1418 biopsies from 766 subfertile men.

AU - Schulze, Wolfgang

AU - Thoms, F

AU - Knuth, U A

PY - 1999

Y1 - 1999

N2 - The introduction of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) has revolutionized treatment of male-factor infertility. Even with a single spermatozoon a pregnancy can be achieved. In cases of azoospermia due to obstruction or highly impaired spermatogenesis, spermatozoa can be retrieved directly from testicular tissue recovered by testicular biopsy followed by sperm extraction. The predictive value of histology from semi-thin sections of testicular biopsies was assessed in relation to testicular sperm extraction (TESE) results, using 1418 biopsy samples from 766 subfertile men which were evaluated simultaneously using a modified Johnsen score and an ordinal classification system for spermatozoa in TESE samples. In 655 men bilateral samples were available. Based on histological findings and TESE results, the quality of spermatogenesis in the right testes was significantly better than that in the left testes. There was a difference between the two sides in 35.7% of all patients for histology and 32.7% for TESE results. When best results from either testis were used for analysis, 76.9% of all men revealed spermatozoa in TESE preparations, although during histological evaluation of semi-thin sections only 64% of all men had shown mature spermatids. In a core group of 250 azoospermic men without anamnestic hints to obstruction and most likely to benefit from ICSI, TESE was successful in 62.8% men. Subdivision of this group dependent on follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) serum concentrations revealed that even in cases of increased FSH concentration, between 39.1 and 64.7% of men showed mature spermatids in their TESE samples. A subset of 70 azoospermic men from the main sample with symptoms and history suggestive of an obstruction and considered as positive controls showed a positive TESE result in all patients. The histology had failed to predict this in 2.9% of all cases. Nevertheless, in five men an early stage of testicular tumour (carcinoma in situ = CIS) was detected. Two of these males suffered from bilateral CIS. This reflects a prevalence of 0.7% testicular malignancy in the group of patients without a history of excurrent duct obstruction. The data demonstrate that a trial TESE with histology based on the semi-thin sectioning technique is a powerful diagnostic and therapeutic procedure, which justifies the invasive nature of sperm retrieval for ICSI. In addition, the results stress the importance of bilateral biopsies to gain optimal diagnostic and therapeutic results.

AB - The introduction of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) has revolutionized treatment of male-factor infertility. Even with a single spermatozoon a pregnancy can be achieved. In cases of azoospermia due to obstruction or highly impaired spermatogenesis, spermatozoa can be retrieved directly from testicular tissue recovered by testicular biopsy followed by sperm extraction. The predictive value of histology from semi-thin sections of testicular biopsies was assessed in relation to testicular sperm extraction (TESE) results, using 1418 biopsy samples from 766 subfertile men which were evaluated simultaneously using a modified Johnsen score and an ordinal classification system for spermatozoa in TESE samples. In 655 men bilateral samples were available. Based on histological findings and TESE results, the quality of spermatogenesis in the right testes was significantly better than that in the left testes. There was a difference between the two sides in 35.7% of all patients for histology and 32.7% for TESE results. When best results from either testis were used for analysis, 76.9% of all men revealed spermatozoa in TESE preparations, although during histological evaluation of semi-thin sections only 64% of all men had shown mature spermatids. In a core group of 250 azoospermic men without anamnestic hints to obstruction and most likely to benefit from ICSI, TESE was successful in 62.8% men. Subdivision of this group dependent on follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) serum concentrations revealed that even in cases of increased FSH concentration, between 39.1 and 64.7% of men showed mature spermatids in their TESE samples. A subset of 70 azoospermic men from the main sample with symptoms and history suggestive of an obstruction and considered as positive controls showed a positive TESE result in all patients. The histology had failed to predict this in 2.9% of all cases. Nevertheless, in five men an early stage of testicular tumour (carcinoma in situ = CIS) was detected. Two of these males suffered from bilateral CIS. This reflects a prevalence of 0.7% testicular malignancy in the group of patients without a history of excurrent duct obstruction. The data demonstrate that a trial TESE with histology based on the semi-thin sectioning technique is a powerful diagnostic and therapeutic procedure, which justifies the invasive nature of sperm retrieval for ICSI. In addition, the results stress the importance of bilateral biopsies to gain optimal diagnostic and therapeutic results.

M3 - SCORING: Zeitschriftenaufsatz

VL - 14

SP - 82

EP - 96

JO - HUM REPROD

JF - HUM REPROD

SN - 0268-1161

IS - 1

M1 - 1

ER -